The book of Ecclesiastes is said to be written by “the Preacher, the son of David, king in Jerusalem.” (Eccl 1:1) It presents itself as a diligent search for the meaning of life in the face of the overriding impression that life is “vanity,” that is, empty and without meaning. This is also the search for wisdom (1:17). But the mood from the beginning is extremely doubtful about the outcome. There is much observation about life and nature (it is here that we find the inspiration for Pete Seeger’s “Turn, Turn, Turn” – 3:1-8). But words of hope and faith are few and far between.
Again, as with the Song of Solomon, we may well ask, “What is this book doing in the Bible?” I had a teacher once who said that you could summarize the contents of Scripture as being “the truth about God” except for Ecclesiastes; so he had emended it to “the truth about God and humanity.”) I’m no longer sure that is true; I find much specifically theological truth in Ecclesiastes.
Some teachers see here a deep skepticism about life itself that forms a sort of black hole in the biblical writings. In this case, “vanity” (the Hebrew hebel) is understood to refer to the permanent pointlessness of human existence. Other teachers see a breath of hope if “vanity” is rather the pointlessness of sinful human existence; passages such as 3:12-22, assigned for today’s reading, are seen to affirm that only in God is meaning found, but that meaning definitely is found in God.
I find that the place of Ecclesiastes in the Bible seems anchored by two things. First, the whole book seems to be a very fine commentary on Genesis 3:17-19, the specific nature of the curse that God brings upon humanity after the fall into sin. Second, it is surprising how much of the language of Ecclesiastes and its hard look at life is reflected in the particular phrases of Jesus’ teaching. For instance, Ecclesiastes 1:3 asks, “What advantage does a person have in all his work which he does under the sun?” In the same harsh phraseology, Jesus asks, “What advantage does a person have if he gains the whole world, and loses his soul? (Mark 8:36). Discerning minds need to know.
Three summers ago I chose to study the whole of Ecclesiastes, and I had a great time doing it. I was grateful for the commentary of Derek Kidner, who unfailingly brought out both the harsh realities and the real comforts of the book. It was a poignant time. My mother had died in April, and during that summer we went back east to a gathering of the Dorman tribe in New York, which included a memorial service for Mom and her burial in the family plot. And I heard the final word on the subject matter of Ecclesiastes in the cemetery, as I stood at the edge of the open grave and listened to the words of Paul from 1 Corinthians 15: 54-58: “Death is swallowed up in victory. O Death, where is your victory, O death, where is your sting? … Therefore, my beloved brethren, be steadfast, immovable, always abounding in the work of the Lord, knowing that your toil in the Lord is never in vain.” That day, with the evidence of life’s futility lying before me, I once again chose hope, and joy, and the Living One.
Respond:
Life has a way of convincing us, from time to time, of its own pointlessness. And it has a point. But Jesus promises the transformation of life into His Life. This is a gift for us, and through us to those we love. What deeper wisdom can there be, than to seek the gift of His life?
Pray:
Come, let us worship and bow down. Let us kneel before the Lord our God, our Maker. For He is our God, and we are the people of His pasture, the sheep of his hands. Psalm 95:6-7
- Dave Dorman